Lessons from the Witness Stand: What Every Nursing Expert Needs to Know

woman on witness stand in courtroomImagine sitting in the witness stand, facing cross-examination, when opposing counsel pulls out a report you wrote years ago. They’re ready to use it to undermine your credibility. Would you be confident in how your words hold up—or nervous about contradictions? For legal nurse consultants, expert witness work is rewarding, but it also comes with high stakes that I learned in the 25 years I testified as an expert sitting in the witness stand.

The Role of the Expert Witness

Attorneys count on experts not only to analyze records but to educate them, juries, and judges. The Federal Rules of Evidence require that testimony be grounded in reliable principles and sufficient data—not speculation. For LNCs, this means reports must be objective, methodical, and rooted in medical facts.

Over time, courts have moved toward requiring experts to testify only within their own specialty. A nurse testifies about nursing practice; a physician testifies about medicine. Attorneys who attempt to substitute one for the other quickly learn judges won’t accept it. This makes LNCs indispensable when cases hinge on nursing standards of care.

Different Types of Reports

You may be asked to contribute to several forms of expert witness reports:

  • Affidavits or certificates of merit to confirm cases are meritorious.

  • Narrative reports that detail medical events and your opinions.

  • Supplemental reports after new evidence, such as depositions, becomes available.

  • Rebuttal reports that directly address an opposing expert’s claims.

Each has its purpose, and all demand precision. Attorneys rely on your report to frame direct examination and prepare for cross-examination on the witness stand. If your report is vague, incomplete, or sloppy, it weakens the case.

Standards of Care and Objectivity

Central to every report is the standard of care. What would a reasonably prudent nurse have done under the circumstances? This is not about hindsight or holding nurses to the standard of perfection. It’s about measuring actions against professional expectations at the time events occurred.

Definitive language is vital. Phrases like “it’s possible” or “maybe” undermine the strength of your opinion. Attorneys—and juries—expect clarity. If you believe the standard of care was breached, state it firmly: “To a reasonable degree of nursing probability, Nurse X deviated from the standard of care by failing to…”

Professionalism in Practice

Expert witness work isn’t only about what you write; it’s also about how you conduct yourself.

  • Be clear on who hired you. Confusion about plaintiff vs. defense representation can be disastrous.

  • Keep accurate records of time and billing. Inflated hours or careless recording keeping can damage your reputation permanently.

  • Maintain testimony lists for at least four years, as required in federal cases.

  • Clearly label your final copy of your report to avoid mishaps during discovery.

Above all, honesty and reliability will keep attorneys coming back. Repeat business comes not just from skill, but from being easy to work with and consistently thorough.

Avoiding Cross-Examination Traps

Opposing counsel will look for inconsistencies, vague opinions, or errors. They may pull past reports or deposition transcripts to highlight contradictions. Being objective from the start—and carefully reviewing each report—helps protect your credibility when you’re on the witness stand.

The way you write your expert report has a direct relationship to the strength of the cross-examination – if the opposing counsel is skilled in probing for holes in your opinion.

Expert witness work is demanding, but it also sets you apart in the legal nurse consulting world. Attorneys seek out professionals who understand the nuances of reports, federal and state regulations, and the courtroom environment. If you want to grow your consulting business, developing confidence in this area is a must.

The good news? You don’t have to learn it all alone. At the 12th LNC Success Online Conference, you’ll hear from experts who have built thriving practices and navigated the challenges of expert witness work. This event is your opportunity to strengthen your skills, expand your knowledge, and connect with a supportive community of LNCs. Register now to reserve your place. Go to http://LNC.tips/Nov25.

Pat IyerPat Iyer is president of The Pat Iyer Group, which develops resources to assist LNCs in obtaining more clients, making more money, and achieving their business goals and dreams.

Have you heard the most recent podcasts on Legal Nurse Podcast? The show is in its 9th year, putting it in the top 1% of all podcasts for its longevity. Watch our podcast on YouTube at http://LNC.tips/YouTube.

Join our Facebook group, LNC Business Growth Circle, to be part of our LNC community.

Pat’s related websites include the podcasts broadcast at podcast.legalnursebusiness.com, and writing tips supplied at patiyer.com.

Get all of Pat’s content in one place by downloading the mobile app, Expert Edu at www.legalnursebusiness.com/expertedu. Watch videos, listen to podcasts, read blogs, watch online courses and training, and more.