Expert witness report writing is a cornerstone of effective communication between healthcare professionals and the legal system. A precise, informative, and objective report can often be the key factor in determining a case’s outcome. However, for beginners, navigating the nuances of expert report writing can be daunting, potentially leading to critical errors that jeopardize credibility and effectiveness.
This post will help aspiring legal nurse consultants (LNCs) avoid common pitfalls and expand their report-writing skills into a guide outlining essential tips from seasoned experts in the field.
Focus on Relevance:
- Mistake: Detailing insignificant deviations from the standard of care.
- Example: Highlighting a nurse’s failure to document minor patient interactions that did not impact the case’s outcome.
Resist the temptation to delve into inconsequential deviations from the standard of care. Your report should provide a clear path from the case’s starting point to its resolution without unnecessary distractions.
Establish Clarity in Client Representation:
- Mistake: Confusion regarding which party has hired the LNC.
- Example: Writing a report suited for the defense when the LNC’s client represents the plaintiff.
Clarify which side has retained your services to ensure alignment between your report and its legal strategy. Misunderstandings in this regard can lead to reports that miss the mark entirely.
Discerning When to Write:
- Mistake: Proceeding with a report despite being unable to assist the hiring side.
- Example: Drafting a report despite realizing that the LNC cannot support the client’s case after reviewing the material.
Exercise discretion when deciding whether to proceed with a written report. If you cannot assist in reviewing the case material, communicate promptly with the hiring attorney to avoid unnecessary efforts.
Substantiate Your Opinions:
- Mistake: Offering unsubstantiated “net opinions.”
- Example: Asserting that nursing staff adhered to the standard of care without providing specific examples or evidence from the case.
Avoid offering unsubstantiated “net opinions.” Provide specific details and evidence supporting your conclusions to fortify the credibility of your report.
Procrastination:
- Mistake: Delaying report writing until the last minute.
- Example: Rushing to complete a report on the eve of the deadline, leading to errors and omissions in the analysis.
The enemy of quality is procrastination. Timeliness is paramount in report writing. Procrastination breeds stress and increases the likelihood of errors creeping into your analysis.
Embrace Definitiveness:
- Mistake: Using uncertain language that undermines your credibility.
- Example: Stating, “It appears that the nurses followed the standard of care” without providing concrete evidence to support the assertion.
Ambiguity has no place in the legal arena. Be resolute in your opinions and substantiate them with unwavering clarity, eschewing vague language that may undermine your credibility.
Anticipate Counterarguments:
- Mistake: Failing to consider opposing perspectives.
- Example: Overlooking potential challenges to the LNC’s opinions and conclusions raised by the opposing party’s expert witness.
Adopt a proactive approach by considering opposing perspectives and preemptively addressing them in your report. This demonstrates thoroughness and foresight in your analysis.
Exercise Restraint in Language:
- Mistake: Using extreme language that compromises objectivity.
- Example: Describing nursing care as “the worst I’ve ever seen” without providing objective evidence to support the claim.
Maintain objectivity by refraining from employing extreme language that may paint you as an advocate rather than an impartial expert witness.
Stick to Your Expertise:
- Mistake: Allowing attorneys to pressure the LNC into areas beyond their expertise.
- Example: Providing opinions on medical practices outside the scope of the LNC’s nursing expertise.
Resist the urge to stray beyond your expertise, and firmly stand by your convictions even if pressured to venture into unfamiliar territory.
Adherence to Relevant Standards:
- Mistake: Citing standards that do not apply to the case’s timeframe.
- Example: Referencing updated nursing protocols that were not in place during the alleged malpractice.
Ensure that any standards cited in your report are pertinent to the timeframe of the case, bolstering the validity of your analysis.
Harmonize with the Attorney’s Theory:
- Mistake: Failing to align opinions with the attorney’s legal strategy, resulting in conflicting arguments.
- Example: Providing a medical opinion that supports a different cause of action than the one the attorney is pursuing in the case.
Collaborate closely with the attorney to align your opinions with the overarching legal strategy, fostering cohesion and synergy in presenting the case.
Guard Against Overbilling:
- Mistake: Billing for excessive hours beyond reasonable for the task’s complexity.
- Example: Charging 20 hours for reviewing a straightforward medical record.
Exercise prudence in billing practices, ensuring that the hours expended on report preparation are commensurate with the task’s scope and complexity.
Ethical Billing Practices:
- Mistake: Billing for excessive hours beyond reasonable for the task’s complexity.
- Example: Charging 20 hours for reviewing a straightforward medical record.
Uphold ethical standards by billing only for authorized work and maintaining transparency and promptness in billing procedures.
Conciseness is Key:
- Mistake: Billing for unauthorized work or services not agreed upon with the attorney.
- Example: Inflating the hours spent on a task without the attorney’s knowledge or approval.
Keep your reports concise and focused, adhering to a prescribed length that prioritizes pertinent information over extraneous details.
Safeguard Your Reports:
- Mistake: Failing to keep secure backups of reports, risking data loss and potential legal issues.
- Example: Losing all copies of a report due to a computer malfunction, leading to delays and potential disputes over the report’s content.
Preserve the integrity of your work by maintaining secure backups of all reports, mitigating the risk of data loss and potential repercussions.
Conclusion
By being mindful of these potential pitfalls and implementing the suggested solutions, you can enhance the quality and effectiveness of your expert witness practice.
Mastering the art of expert report writing is an ongoing journey marked by continuous refinement and adaptation. By adhering to these fundamental principles and heeding the wisdom gleaned from experienced professionals, aspiring legal nurse consultants can navigate the intricacies of report writing with confidence and precision, ultimately enhancing their efficacy as trusted experts in the legal arena.
Following these principles and practices can establish yourself as a trusted and sought-after expert.
Get my latest book, How to be a Successful Nursing Expert Witness, Second Edition.
It offers valuable, actionable tips. Order it here.
This book is for new and established nursing experts.
Pat Iyer is president of The Pat Iyer Group, which develops resources to assist LNCs in obtaining more clients, making more money, and achieving their business goals and dreams.
Have you heard the most recent podcasts on Legal Nurse Podcast? The show is in its 8th year, putting it in the top 1% of all podcasts for its longevity. Watch our podcast on YouTube at http://LNC.tips/YouTube.
Join our Facebook group, LNC Business Growth Circle, to be part of our LNC community.
Pat’s related websites include the continuing education provided on LNCEU.com, the podcasts broadcast at podcast.legalnursebusiness.com, and writing tips supplied at patiyer.com.
Get all of Pat’s content in one place by downloading the mobile app, Expert Edu at www.legalnursebusiness.com/expertedu. Watch videos, listen to podcasts, read blogs, watch online courses and training, and more.